Given that Felix Mendelssohn was one of the greatest pianists of his age, it is surprising that his writing for his own instrument has not stood the test of time, unlike his large-scale orchestral and choral works. The sonatas are not seen as breaking new ground and it’s only the sets of Lieder ohne Worte that have held their own on record and in the concert hall. His 20th-century reputation is for Victorian sentimentality and lack of depth, so his music feels ripe for reassessment. This appealing selection of early pieces – a sonata, some “characteristic pieces”, a capriccio and the lovely first book of Songs Without Words – reveals a young composer following in the footsteps of Clementi, Hummel and Weber while still paying homage to the great J.S. Bach. There’s plenty to delight here. The madcap Capriccio in F-Sharp Minor, Op 5 is all scurrying figurations and galumphing leaps with a cleverly interpolated fugue in the middle. The seven Charakterstücke are a revelation: crafted, varied and imaginative genre pieces foreshadowing Schumann. The only disappointment is the pretty but rather rambling sonata. Howard Shelley’s approach is accomplished and respectful, with plenty of insights. Given that so much of…
July 17, 2013
Eton College was founded by King Henry VI in 1443 and within 50 years had amassed a unique body of English choral music collected together in what is known today as the Eton Choirbook. Given the collection’s focus on devotion to the Blessed Virgin, its survival of the Henrician Reformation of the 1530s is a minor miracle. The Sixteen made a recommendable recorded foray into this repertoire back in the 1990s, but the choir of Oxford’s Christ Church Cathedral has two special claims to authenticity: first, as a group with an unbroken tradition of daily choral services and second, and most importantly, the inclusion of 14 boy sopranos amongst 33 exclusively male voices. Boys’ voices are less common in recordings of the Eton pieces, probably because of the discipline required to tackle unaccompanied works on this scale. Of the five pieces here, four involve over 15 minutes of complex polyphony and one, Lambe’s titanic O Maria plena gracia, weighs in at over 20 minutes – an intonational endurance test, as any singer will tell you. That these singers carry all before them is a tribute to their conductor Stephen Darlington, who directs his substantial forces with flair and a…
July 17, 2013
Orchestras around the world are increasing their activities in the field of education and community outreach.
July 15, 2013
Our next stop after Lyon was Polyfollia, a festival of choral music from all across the world held in Normandy. We tackled the challenge of loading 41 choristers, nine adults, and over 50 suitcases onto our TGV to Paris with grande vitesse and sat back to enjoy the French countryside pass us by. On arrival in Paris, we were met by Felicity and Richard, chaperones par excellence who formed a crucial part of the Polyfollia team of volunteers who would look after us so well for the next week. Since 2004, Polyfollia has been welcoming choirs to contribute to a magnificent aural and visual feast in wonderful venues across the north of France. This year’s festival was the third for Artistic Director and Founder of the choir, Lyn Williams, who said she "enjoys Polyfollia more each time [she] comes back". Once we’d settled into our university accommodation, we headed to meet the Estonian TV Girls’ Choir and their conductor, Aarne Saluveer. Over the course of the evening we got to know our fellow singers and conductors by singing for each other and chatting over supper. This sort of choral sharing across international borders is central to Polyfollia’s excellence as a festival,…
July 12, 2013
One acerbic US critic dismissed Shostakovich’s Leningrad Symphony as “a woolly mammoth which emerged after the Stalinist freeze”. Once upon a time I would have said, “I wish I’d thought of that!” Now, I’m not so sure. Yes, it’s still a sacred monster and Gergiev’s reading lasts more than 82 minutes (two and a half minutes longer than his previous effort, which also featured the bizarre combination of both the Rotterdam and Kirov orchestras because, apparently, the composer wanted the work played by two ensembles – a fact new to me). However, I’d forgotten just how much of the score is actually quite dark and brooding. This reading has none of the agonized, self-dramatised protraction of Bernstein’s mid- 1980s version with the Chicago Symphony (his only recorded foray with that orchestral war machine) which clocks in at 85 minutes. In this version with the Mariinsky Orchestra (formerly Kirov) Gergiev demonstrates again what a superb orchestral builder he is. Unlike, say, Petrenko in Liverpool, whose orchestra has long had exposure through a large of body of recordings, the Kirov Orchestra was largely unknown in the West before Gergiev’s emergence as a major podium force. There’s little agit- prop bombast here, and……
July 10, 2013
The Venezuelan educator and politician José Antonio Abreu has added another string to his bow, one to sit proudly alongside his Simón Bolívar Youth Orchestra, firebrand conductor Gustavo Dudamel and a revolutionary approach to music education, El Sistema modern recordings in the catalogue presented in the familiar warm acoustic associated with the Yellow Label. The main reason for my unreserved praise lies with the viscerally exciting take on the criminally neglected Argentinean Alberto Ginastera’s First Quartet from 1948. There have been several recordings (an initiative which now has its first local teacher based in Adelaide). Comprised of four of his orchestra’s string section leaders, he has devised an exciting young ensemble of the highest order. In their debut recording, the Simón Bolívar Quartet presents a wisely chosen program bringing together three seemingly disparate composers in Ginastera, Dvorák and Shostakovich. Dvorák’s popular American quartet was written during the composer’s stay in the States and develops its own specific folk motifs – it’s this ingenious idea that brings together a trio of geographically separated composers on this fine disc. In his Eighth Quartet Shostakovich goes even further, quoting his own earlier Trio Op 67. In itself it’s a lament for the…
July 10, 2013
The two extremes of Schumann’s personality exist side by side in the two sets of pieces recorded here. The Fantasiestücke of 1837 alternate between the introverted, reflective Schumann (his Eusebius alter ego) and the extrovert, somewhat manic Schumann (Florestan). No wonder, as the sleeve note states, this was regarded as “difficult and private music”. In the eight Kreisleriana of the following year, Schumann juxtaposed these expressive extremes more blatantly, even chaotically. Pianists attempting these pieces not only require considerable fluency at the keyboard; they need to convey the sudden changes of attitude. When that is achieved, as it is here, the music springs to life and the work of Schumann’s contemporaries seems impersonal by comparison. As befitting a great chamber musician, Imogen Cooper’s strengths lie in the detail of her playing and a finely honed ability to separate important thematic material from accompaniment in thicker textures. While reflective moments are bewitchingly otherworldly in her hands, she finds power in the fast music without resorting to overemphasis (or, let’s be frank, bashing). Cooper is equally at home in the variations Brahms transcribed from his String Sextet Op 18, but the prize of this disc is the Schumann, where a distinguished…
July 10, 2013
Choral music aficionados will love this program, featuring as it does two great mass settings of the twentieth century, Frank Martin’s Mass for Double Choir and Maurice Duruflé’s Requiem. Both works in their own way exude a very Gallic musical and spiritual sensibility. Martin’s a cappella Mass is an early work and reflects something of his Swiss Calvinist upbringing, but its austerity is relieved with some lush harmony derived from his love of French composers Franck and Debussy. Duruflé’s Requiem is a thoroughly Catholic affair, based largely on the plainsong Mass for the Dead but clothed in a luxuriously colourful harmonic idiom. The St George’s Consort, an adult ensemble formed in 2008, handles the Martin with equal amounts of skill and passion. As in all choral music recordings, a balance has to be struck between closely observed vocal power and the enchantment of distance. In the Martin, the balance is tipped in favour of immediacy. This allows for sections like the Pleni sunt coeli of the Sanctus, with its motoric rhythms, to make maximum impact as well as showing how capable the group is of sustaining long phrases like those in the Agnus Dei. The cathedral choir and consort together…
July 10, 2013
After an exuberant time in Barcelona, we met at the Palau de Musica a final time to get on the bus to Lyon. Over the course of the journey, the choristers had the opportunity to capture their impressions of tour so far, in whichever art form they desired. An esteemed judging panel at the front of the bus received musical compositions (both original and arrangements), sketches, poems, videos and photos. In the end, Abel’s original interpretation of the Barcelona streetscape (below) most impressed the panel. We arrived in Lyon at the statue of Saint-Exupery and his little Prince to meet our host choir, La Cigale de Lyon and their vivacious director, Anne-Marie Cabut. As the choristers met their billet families, they engaged in enthusiastic practising of various levels of French. After a much-needed night’s sleep, we reconvened in Place Belle Cour the next morning, to meet Roland and Caroline, two parents of La Cigale members who had volunteered their time to show us around town for the day. Before heading off to see the sights, we began the day with a rehearsal in order to revitalise our interpretations – checking details that may have been forgotten, realigning our singing and performing…
July 9, 2013
My favourite thing about Pollock Halls is undoubtedly breakfast time. And a big breakfast was definitely necessary for the trip to Dundee for the Scottish Chamber Orchestra tonight. The backstory: last week I met with Gabrielle the CEO of AWO (Australian World Orchestra) for hot chocolate, becoming their inaugural mentee for their new mentoring program helping young people explore music abroad. Alison Mitchell is my mentor, who was guest flute professor/my teacher at Sydney Con for my first year, and currently is back in action with SCO as principle player and soloist tonight. I was also presented with a bonus of 30 pounds in cash to spend on more hot chocolate, after signing my name to some terms and conditions which works on the small condition that I keep a written blog. So this morning, I ate three eggs cooked three different ways, giant wild mushrooms and grilled kipper. I sat with a Russian girl who drank two coffees and appeared to be 20 but was actually 13. In the afternoon I took a bus into the city centre costing one pound and fifty pence, which clanged into a tin till box, and took a seat on the tartan bus-seats. A man on the…
July 7, 2013
The past week for the Sydney Children’s Choir can only be described as a whirlwind. On Tuesday the choir gave a farewell lunchtime concert at the City Recital Hall providing that all-important confirmation that we were indeed ready to go. As soon as the final round of warm applause had dissipated, we made our way down to the Sydney Opera House where we had the honour of appearing at the memorial concert for Hazel Hawke, singing to no fewer than five Australian prime ministers, all within the hour! After a slight lull in the whirlwind to check that everything was in fact in the suitcase, including our assortment of percussion instruments, the choir arrived at Sydney airport with palpable excitement. The trip afforded opportunities for catching up on the latest films, knotting friendship bracelets, sketching and the composition of the odd symphony. After the torrential rain of Sydney in the recent weeks, the choir was delighted to step off the plane into the Barcelona summer. To stave off the jetlag as much as possible, we headed for the Castel at Montjuic offering panoramic views of the city against the azure backdrop of the Mediterranean. The highlight of the sight-seeing was the world-renowned…
July 3, 2013
York Bowen (1884-1961) is probably the most important forgotten British composer to be “rediscovered” in recent years. The cause has been taken up by labels like Hyperion, Dutton and Chandos, with outstanding champions in Stephen Hough, Sir Andrew Davis and Lawrence Power. This latest Hyperion exploration of the complete works for violin and piano has fallen to violinist Chloë Hanslip and the current doyen of Bowen pianists, Danny Driver, whose revealing survey of the piano sonatas won plaudits all round in 2010. The major works here are the late Violin Sonata and the Suite for Violin and Piano, but there are a host of smaller occasional works ranging from the substantial Phantasie, a Cobbett commission in 1911, down to tasty soupçons like the Kreisleresque Bolero and the winsome Allegretto. Bowen was a proficient violist as well as a prodigious concert pianist, rendering these works highly “playable”. He was also a master of the dividing line between serious and light, with a gift for a memorable idea that imbues even the slightest work with charm and spirit. Driver and Hanslip turn out to be a match made in heaven and respond to Bowen’s idiom with grace, taste and sensitivity. Recognising that…
July 2, 2013