CD and Other Review

Review: Stravinsky, Mahler (Australian World Orchestra/Mehta)

Last year’s celebration of Australia’s musical elite diaspora, the Australian World Orchestra, (plus a few resident players) featured Zubin Mehta on the podium. I’ve always regarded Mehta as a superb “technician” but, apart from a wunderkind debut Bruckner Ninth, while still in his twenties with the Vienna Philharmonic, I’ve never found his interpretations particularly engaging.   However, my reactions to this two CD set of the occasion has somewhat changed my thinking. Their performance of Stravinsky’s The Rite of Spring, in its centenary year, is very fine- without challenging Doráti’s, Bernstein’s first New York version or Igor Markevich’s old Philharmonia (stereo) version where the orchestral shriek at the opening of the second section is truly blood curdling. I don’t think I’ve ever heard the treacherous opening bassoon passage so beautifully shaped. The woodwind is also beautifully captured throughout.  Mehta’s tempi are steady rather than headlong. The performance of  Mahler’s First Symphony was a treat. Mehta included the discarded Blumine (“Flowers’) movement ( as he did in his Israel Philharmonic recording in the late eighties) although Mahler was probably right to remove it, as it sounds genuinely, as distinct from faux, naïve. The string playing was of a caliber we seldom…

November 21, 2014
CD and Other Review

Review: DVORAK: New World Symphony; R STRAUSS: Also Sprach Zarathustra (Israel PO/Mehta)

Zubin Mehta has had a distinguished, if occasionally uneven career. His tenure with the New York Philharmonic was not one of the orchestra’s more successful appointments. Elsewhere he has done some outstanding work: his conducting of Turandot on Decca with Sutherland is probably the finest on disc, Richard Bonynge observing that Mehta’s scrupulous attention to detail at the recording sessions was remarkable. More recently he led the less famous forces in Valencia in a remarkable Ring Cycle. Now we have this new release from a concert he gave with the IPO in Tel-Aviv in 2007. From the outset, Dvorák’s Ninth is flabby and untidy, with the IPO’s strings sounding very indifferent. This is surprising, for the one of the IPO’s greatest strengths has always been its famous string section. There is some fine solo woodwind playing in the slow movement and the scherzo clips along nicely. Nonetheless, you don’t have to look far to find superior performances on CD. The New World Symphony is teamed with Strauss’s Also Sprach Zarathustra, and as couplings go it doesn’t get much stranger than this. What some orchestras can present together in a concert hall may seem incongruous on a recording…. Continue reading Get…

October 12, 2011