Developed over several years at the Hayes, Silver Tongue is a queer reimagining of Robert Louis Stevenson’s classic adventure novel Treasure Island.

Featuring music and lyrics by Alec Steedman, and a book by Jacob Parker and Miranda Middleton, it centres on the relationship between young Jim Hawkins and Long John Silver – here rebranded as the female Silver Tongue, the former first mate (nautically and romantically) of Captain Flint (also female), who abandoned her.

Silver Tongue

Billie Palin as the title character in Silver Tongue. Photo © John McRae

When Jim discovers Flint’s treasure map, he is determined to set sail with Silver and her band of pirates in search of adventure, and to discover his own story and what happened to his mother.

By combining two different types of storytelling – rollicking adventure and emotional tales about lost love and coming of age – the structure of the show doesn’t feel centred and some of the focus is dissipated.

This is reflected in the score. The show opens with a terrific upbeat number evoking a “yo ho ho and a bottle of rum” type of pirate drinking song that sets the scene perfectly. And with all the cast playing musical instruments – from violins, accordion, piano, cello and cymbals to large barrels as drums – the robust intro draws us in.

But the somewhat anodyne, soul-searching ballads sit oddly among the rollicking numbers with their sea shanty and folk influences, and don’t have a strong impact.

On top of that, some of the scenes draw on pantomime, particularly the portrayal of the pompous, inept Squire Trelawney, who captains the ship – sorry, yacht – taking Silver, Jim and the pirates to Skeleton Island and the buried treasure. He’s never been to sea before, but he captained his under 11 cricket team so, as far as he’s concerned, he’s qualified.

Richard Carroll directs the show on an effective set designed by Hailley Hunt, featuring canvas drapes, ropes, barrels and a few wooden benches, while Sam Hernandez’s costumes work well.

Musical Director Victoria Falconer helps drive the action from onstage in the role of Silver’s parrot Peg (evoked through colourful feathers in her hair). The show’s composer also appears as an onstage violinist.

Carroll keeps the action moving with lively direction, but the different storytelling styles interrupt the flow, and some of the humour defeats him. There are a lot of groan-worthy jokes (along the Dick and Fanny line), many of which aren’t particularly funny and fall flat, despite the best efforts of the cast, among them Natalie Abbott, who plays Dick and who can find the humour in pretty well anything.

Silver Tongue

The company of Silver Tongue. Photo © John McRae

There are also quite a few “in” theatre jokes to do with vocal rest and narrative devices that showbiz people will understand and enjoy – the opening night audience roared with laughter – but which are unlikely to resonate to the same degree with the general public.

Billie Palin brings the right kind of brazen swagger and comic nous to the character of Silver Tongue, while Marty Alix is a gentle, understated Jim, singing with lovely warmth.

Representing the British establishment – with a nod to Gilbert & Sullivan – Jack Green is very funny as the bungling, deluded Squire Trelawney, who is prone to over-pronunciation. Shannen Alyce Quan is also amusing as the Squire’s sidekick Doctor Livesey, while the relationship between Livesey, Dick and Hands (played by Tana Laga’aia) is very sweet.

The show never quite hits its mark because it doesn’t seem to know whether it’s a rollicking adventure, a rom-com, a coming-of-age drama or a pantomime. That said, there are pleasures to be had from the score and fun to be found in the production, as well as some strong, entertaining performances. Musicals take a long time to hone, and this production is another step in the show’s development.


Silver Tongue plays at the Hayes Theatre Co, Potts Point, Sydney until 19 December. More information here.

Save 37% on a Limelight annual digital subscription. Offer ends 27 November