Roderick Williams’ survey of English song, A Shropshire Lad, has been awarded the coveted title of Limelight Recording of the Year 2023.

The British baritone – seen recently in glorious voice at the coronation – not only devised and performed the program, he orchestrated each song himself. The disc also features the Manchester-based Hallé conducted by Sir Mark Elder. The recording is on the orchestra’s own label (Hallé CDHLL7559) and is also honoured as Vocal Recording of the Year.

Recording of the Year

“This is a huge thrill,” said Williams. “To have been invited to record a solo disc with Sir Mark and the Hallé was already an honour and a joy. To have a world-class orchestra play and record my orchestrations took that joy to another level. However, recognition from Limelight that our efforts were enjoyed and thus rewarded is icing on an already pretty delicious slice of cake.”

Williams’ program takes as its launchpad George Butterworth’s moving cycle of Housman settings, intricately orchestrated to bring out every ounce of colour and meaning.

From there, Williams’ imagination encompasses composers from Vaughan Williams and Ireland to Ruth Gipps and Rebecca Clarke. “While much of the music has been familiar to me for decades, I was particularly pleased to explore songs by female composers,” he said. “I hope these recordings will help to expand the reach of their music.”

“Williams indulges in some gorgeous word-painting – his epic-yet-intimate treatment of John Ireland’s Sea Fever is especially powerful,” wrote reviewer Will Yeoman.

“He is equally adept at handling solo instruments. I’m thinking of the solo violin in Ina Boyle’s The Joy of Earth, the cor anglais and cello solos in Butterworth’s The Lads in Their Hundreds, and cor anglais, clarinet and horn in Ernest Farrar’s setting of Silent Noon. Williams’ use of the harp is a joy throughout.”

Roderick Williams
Roderick Williams and Sir Mark Elder in the recording studio. Photo © Alex Burns/The Hallé

Speaking with Limelight, the singer likens the opportunity to record these songs to being let loose in a sweet shop.

“I found it difficult to concentrate on my singing, which is, after all, my primary function, because I was too busy listening to the array of sounds the orchestra was making,” he said. “I was deeply touched by the care and professionalism the players invested in my writing. And Sir Mark’s attention to balance and nuance was immaculate; he treated what I had written with such respect, while bringing the wealth of his experience to bear. That was a lesson in itself.”

“Williams, Elder and the Hallé are a match made in heaven,” wrote Yeoman. “I’ve listened again and again to the Butterworth and marvelled again and again at Williams’ clarity of diction, beauty of timbre and forceful expression. And at Elder and his orchestra’s ability not merely to support but to embed Williams in such a carefully calibrated and variegated garden of sonic bliss.”

Williams’ program takes as its launchpad George Butterworth’s moving cycle of Housman settings, intricately orchestrated to bring out every ounce of colour and meaning.

From there, Williams’ imagination encompasses composers from Vaughan Williams and Ireland to Ruth Gipps and Rebecca Clarke. “While much of the music has been familiar to me for decades, I was particularly pleased to explore songs by female composers,” he said. “I hope these recordings will help to expand the reach of their music.”

“Williams indulges in some gorgeous word-painting – his epic-yet-intimate treatment of John Ireland’s Sea Fever is especially powerful,” wrote reviewer Will Yeoman.

“He is equally adept at handling solo instruments. I’m thinking of the solo violin in Ina Boyle’s The Joy of Earth, the cor anglais and cello solos in Butterworth’s The Lads in Their Hundreds, and cor anglais, clarinet and horn in Ernest Farrar’s setting of Silent Noon. Williams’ use of the harp is a joy throughout.”

 

Runners Up

Mein Traum

Mein Traum

Works: Music by Schubert, Weber et al.
Performers: Stéphane Degout, Pygmalion/Raphaël Pichon
Label: Harmonia Mundi HMM905345

Tom and Will King's Singers Fretwork

Tom + Will

Works: Choral music by Weelkes & Byrd
Performers: The King’s Singers, Fretwork
Label: Signum Classics SIGCD731

Category Winners

Orchestral Recording of the Year

Fabio Luisi’s recording of Carl Nielsen’s Symphonies with the Danish National Symphony Orchestra bowled the Limelight panel over to win the orchestral category (DG 4863471).

“I am very proud and happy for this award,” said Luisi. “The work we did in the last years, especially on this composer, has projected this orchestra into the circle of the world’s best.”

In a detailed review, Phillip Scott put Luisi’s readings at the top of a competitive pile. “These are distinguished performances, packed with moments where you think, ‘That’s exactly how it should go,” he wrote.

“Nielsen speaks to me as a composer with a very personal, authentic and original language, a surprising honesty and a fantastic use of orchestral colours. Humour, the courage of simplicity, but also depth of feelings are qualities I specially love,” Luisi told Limelight. “Surprising, and somehow unexpected, was the joy of recording the symphonies from all participants and the determination to do not just well or better, but the best. The positive and joyful spirit has been a unique moment for me. 

Runners up

Hollywood Soundstage

Hollywood Soundstage

Works: Music by Korngold, Waxman et al.
Performers: Sinfonia of London/John Wilson
Label: Chandos CHAN5294

Czech Philharmonic Mahler

Mahler

Works: Symphony No. 5
Performers: Czech Philharmonic Orchestra/Semyon Bychkov
Label: Pentatone PTC5187021

Chamber Recording of the Year

The Silesian Quartet’s seven-disc survey of Mieczysław Weinberg’s String Quartets is both revelatory and inspiring (Accord ACD320).

“We feel especially honoured by this award, as we consider the Weinberg box to be the most important release in the history of our ensemble,” said violinist Szymon Krzeszowiec. “The Silesian Quartet has released more than 50 albums, many of which have received prestigious awards. However, the Limelight award is particularly significant and endearing for us. We are very pleased that Weinberg’s music has made its way to Australia! We are looking forward to presenting it here in live concerts.”

“Every bar and every note feel intimately connected to the composer and his musical thought,” wrote Clive Paget. “Technically it’s immaculate too – and these are difficult works with treacherous, exposed lines and contrapuntal complexities. Intonation is faultless, even at hair-raising speeds, and there’s a deeply involving sense of ensemble.”

“Mieczysław Wajnberg, a composer and pianist of Jewish origin, was born in Warsaw and graduated from the conservatory in Poland before the outbreak of World War II,” explained Krzeszowiec. “He and his family fled to the Soviet Union, but he made it abroad alone. His parents and siblings became victims of the Holocaust. He always said that he treated Poland like a lost homeland. Today, we feel a significant responsibility to promote his music and treat his legacy as a national cultural treasure.”

Runners up

An album cover, a warm yellow, green glow colour.

Prism V

Works: String Quartets by Beethoven, Webern and Bach
Performers: Danish String Quartet
Label: ECM 4858469

Mozart

Works: Violin Sonatas
Performers: Renaud Capuçon, Kit Armstrong
Label: DG 4864463 (4CD) 

Instrumental Recording of the Year

Bertrand Chamayou’s reading of Messiaen’s Vingt Regards sur l’enfant Jésus is a worthy winner, full of flair and original ideas (Erato 9029619666).

“To receive this prestigious prize from Limelight is extremely moving and meaningful for me. It symbolizes a connection to the Australian audience that I never yet had the chance to experience in life,” said Chamayou. “I truly hope I will be able to come to Australia soon to meet my Australian audience!”

“Chamayou brings to it all his intelligence, understanding and formidable technique,” wrote Steve Moffatt. “The result is insightful, often revelatory, and the feeling is palpable that he is completely at one with this music.”

“I discovered the Vingt Regards when I was a kid (roughly around nine), and it was one of the most striking things that happened to me. It then grew in me for about 30 years,” said Chamayou, who, by the way, dreams of visiting Australia. “Every time I play it, I feel like I’m traveling through my own, whole life. Even if the music is sometimes very extroverted, it’s, in a way, an introspective experience.”

“I first started to record in a small chapel near Paris, but after two days the heating broke down, the temperature dropped to 12 degrees Celsius, so I stopped. We decided to record in the wonderful MC2 in Grenoble one month later. Again, after two to three days, I hurt my left hand while doing several takes of the Regard No. 11 and the doctors asked me to stop playing for one month. I did the final session two months later, without any big problems, but it was still like climbing Mount Everest.”

Runners up

Zimerman Szymanowski

Szymanowski

Works: Masques, Mazurkas, Variations
Performers: Krystian Zimerman
Label:DG 4863007

Benjamin Grosvenor

Schumann & Brahms

Works: Kreisleriana, Variations
Performers: Benjamin Grosvenor
Label: Decca 4853945

Opera Recording of the Year

Performed by The English Concert under conductor Harry Bicket, Handel’s Serse sparkles with passion and good humour (Linn CKD709).

“This recognition serves as a testament to the beauty and emotional depth of Handel’s work,” said Bicket. “I look back on those recording sessions with great fondness and gratitude, knowing we were able to capture the essence of this timeless masterpiece.”

“Handel’s music is sublime, and this is a sublime cast,” wrote Will Yeoman, admiring Emily D’Angelo who sings the title role and describing Bicket and The English Concert’s credentials as self-recommending.

“Recording Serse was an unforgettable journey filled with moments of artistic inspiration and camaraderie,” Bicket said. “The passion and dedication of the entire ensemble, the brilliant cast, and the entire production team made every recording session a joyous and creatively fulfilling experience.”

“This award is a testament to the remarkable talent and commitment of all those involved, and I am thrilled to share this achievement with the entire team who brought Serse to life in a way that continues to move and inspire audiences.”

Runners up

Leoncavallo

Works: Zingari
Performers: Krassimira Stoyanova, Arsen Soghomonyan, Royal Philharmonic/Carlo Rizzi
Label: Opera Rara 9293800612

Meyerbeer Robert le Diable

Meyerbeer

Works: Robert le diable
Performers: John Osborn, Erin Morley, Opéra National de Bordeaux/Marc Minkowski
Label: Bru Zane BZ1045 (3CD) 

Details on how you could win our 2023 Recordings of the Year will be included in the January/February 2024 issue of Limelight.

Subscribe by Monday 18 December to receive a copy.

Contribute to Limelight and support independent arts journalism.