In an unfortunate turn of events, this is a review of the last show being held at Theatre Works’ Explosives Factory venue and Smoke is a perfect example of the utility of such spaces.
It’s impressive, in a way, that the entire cast and creative team of Smoke deliver moments of brilliance smashed together with moments of insufferable creative choices. Debut playwright Hugh Gutteridge transforms political musings into mystical knowledge delivered by a Puck-like spirit that is the personification of ‘uppers’.
But he also writes the women of the play in a grating, unrealistic way, including one girl telling her friend, unironically and accepted as caring advice, to “just be ok” with experiencing an active psychotic break and “make it fashion”.
The cast at times are so theatrical it feels like Smoke is a parody but then they have moments of heartwarming vulnerability and connection with each other that screams end-of-a-big-night authenticity.

Director Bagryana Popov, a seasoned creative – unlike Gutteridge and the cast – sometimes wrangles all the moving parts together to transport the audience to a well loved club, but the incessant comings and goings of the cast on stage is a lacklustre way to signal when the characters are or aren’t privy to conversations.
The quick smart jumps between these highs and lows, particularly in the first half of the show, causes doubt; maybe they’re all doing this on purpose. But an earnestly cringe finale, albeit performed by Anastasia Krstevska with as much poignancy as possible, makes clear that the majority of the team are just artists learning their craft and finding their voice. And that is a process rife with obnoxiousness as we, placing myself in the same boat, move from youthful certainty into the realisation of how much we don’t know.
Gutteridge is keen to show how much he knows about his Zoomer cohort. In doing so he rams a bunch of stereotypical ‘youth’ experiences into 90 minutes. The effect is a play that feels like it’s an extension of America’s early 2000s youth-focused anti-drug media campaign that was prevalent across an array of trendy TV shows – that is, a work that feels simultaneously cool with finger on the youth pulse and dorky with a self-aggrandising tone.
The observations Gutteridge wants to share and his style of writing would suit a polemic, four plus hour long version of this show so each archetype, conflict, realisation and reflection feels earned. Indeed, my plus one commented that Smoke had an energy of Angels in America to it. This speaks to Gutteridge’s undeniable writing talent that hopefully continues to develop.
As theatre venues providing space and resources for artists to hone their craft and as Victoria hurtles toward an election where support for the arts is in doubt, here’s hoping this team and other practitioners will be able to carve out opportunities for themselves to grow.
Smoke plays at the Explosives Factory, St Kilda until 25 November.

Comments
Log in to start the conversation.