Opera Australia has valiantly worked around the unavailability of their usual Melbourne home, the State Theatre, in various ways over the past three years. Opera at the tennis centre was an odd choice, but this family show with no singing is even more strange.

Described as “A Novel Symphony for Actors and Orchestra”, The Trumpet of the Swan is based on the 1971 children’s novel of the same name by E.B. White (Charlotte’s Web, Stuart Little).

This adaptation with music by Jason Robert Brown and book by Marsha Norman was commissioned by Washington DC’s Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts, where it premiered in 2008.

The story follows young, mute swan Louis. He befriends a boy called Sam who helps him learn to read and write, but the other swans can’t read and Louis is unable to woo his dream bird, Serena.

His father steals a trumpet so Louis can express himself. Before the happy ending our hero, sometimes with Sam’s help, embarks on a series of adventures in the human world to earn money to pay for the trumpet.

Arjun Tiwari (centre) in Opera Australia’s The Trumpet of the Swan. Photo courtesy and © Opera Australia

Opera Australia’s semi-staged “storytelling concert” sees Orchestra Victoria on the Regent Theatre stage under the baton of Chad Kelly. They have fun with Brown’s accessible score, which supports character and place through evocative orchestration and leitmotifs (making it reminiscent of Peter and the Wolf, though it’s not as overtly thematic).

Musical highlights include a Philadelphia nightclub scene’s upbeat jazz, and every moment principal trumpet Mark Fitzpatrick gives voice to Louis with his radiant solos.

Director Tyran Parke notes in the program that rehearsals were a matter of days, so the (amplified) speaking cast read their lines throughout the 80-minute performance. A few minor stumbles aside, they convey character and moments of humour through voice and rudimentary physicality.

Bert LaBonté in Opera Australia’s The Trumpet of the Swan. Photo courtesy and © Opera Australia

Bert LaBonté quietly charms with childlike candidness and delight as Sam. Ben Mingay’s father swan is cocky but big-hearted, while Marney McQueen plays the sweet mother swan between voicing numerous minor characters with comically accented gusto, from angry music shop owner to dodgy nightclub boss.

Grant Piro’s main role is voicing Louis’s thoughts with appealing earnestness-meets-whimsy. Lithe dancer Arjun Tiwari interprets the young swan through Freya List’s choreography, which focuses on upper-body dynamism (early on she also gives us a witty little Swan Lake trio). Scout Hook neatly draws Serena with words and movement.

The minimal staging is sometimes engaging, such as when the five “swan support” Victorian College of the Arts students represent flying swans with ostrich-feather fans and stylised 2D clouds.

For the most part, however, the limited props and costumes don’t offer much visual interest, and at times look like something out of cash-strapped amateur theatre.

Arjun Tiwari (centre) in Opera Australia’s The Trumpet of the Swan. Photo courtesy and © Opera Australia

Those seated far from the vast Regent Theatre’s stage will see little most of the time, while junior members of the audience may get bored. Perhaps kids would find an eye-catching prop trumpet, brought to life by the swan supports, more pleasing and easier to understand than the symbolic red cord that Tiwari tenses and twirls.

While the scarcity of quality live performances for families makes The Trumpet of the Swan welcome, it’s not a compelling entry point to orchestral music. The score may be accessible and evocative, but children who don’t already enjoy this kind of music aren’t likely to be persuaded by actors reading from books among a smattering of mostly dinky props.


The Trumpet of the Swan is at the Regent Theatre, Melbourne, until 21 November.

Save 37% on a Limelight annual digital subscription. Offer ends 27 November